Why That Glass of Wine is Not Self-Care

Why That Glass of Wine Isn’t Self-Care

The Lie We’ve All Bought Into

Somewhere along the way, we collectively decided that pouring a glass of wine after a hard day counts as self-care. Open Instagram on any given Friday and you’ll find a thousand variations of the same caption. Mama needs her wine. Self-care Sunday. Wine o’clock. It’s the wellness industry’s chaotic little cousin, and it’s been masquerading as a healing ritual for so long that most of us have stopped questioning it. Babe, we need to question it.

I spent years treating wine like it was a medical intervention. Stressful day at work, pour a glass. Friday night, open a bottle. Bad date, bring on the sauvignon blanc. I genuinely believed I was being kind to myself, and I had the language to back it up. I deserve this. I’ve earned this. I need to unwind. The wine had a whole PR team in my head working around the clock to keep it looking legitimate.

The problem is, self-care has an actual definition, and it’s a really simple one. It’s anything that makes future you better off than she’d be without it. That’s the whole test. And when you hold a Tuesday night glass of wine up to that definition with any honesty at all, the thing falls apart immediately. So let’s talk about what’s actually going on, why neurodivergent brains in particular fall for this trick, and what to do about it.

Why Neurospicy Brains Get Caught In This Loop

If your brain runs hot, you already know what it’s like to end the day completely fried. Sensory overload. Masking through every interaction. The little background hum of overthinking every conversation you’ve had since 2008. By 6pm your nervous system’s basically held together with vibes and an empty water bottle. You don’t want to feel things. You want the volume turned all the way down.

Wine turns the volume down really fast, honey. That’s the appeal. It’s quick. It’s socially acceptable. It comes in a pretty glass and it makes the chatter in your head go quiet for an hour or two. For a brain that’s been screaming since breakfast, that quiet feels like rescue. And here’s where the trap snaps shut, because numbing feels almost identical to regulation when you’ve never actually experienced proper regulation. You think you’re calming down. You’re not. You’re just turning the dial off.

This matters because neurodivergent people are genuinely more vulnerable to this particular flavour of self-deception. Our nervous systems are working harder all day, so the relief feels more dramatic, which makes the habit more sticky, which makes the language we wrap around it more important. If you’ve been calling wine your self-care for years and you’ve got a neurospicy brain, you weren’t being silly. You were managing. But managing and caring aren’t the same thing, and once you can see the difference, you can’t really unsee it.

The Self-Care Test That Changes Everything

Here’s the test I use now, and I promise it’s the simplest thing you’ll read all week. Will future me be better off because of this, or worse off? That’s the whole question. If the answer is better off, it’s care. If the answer is worse off, it’s coping. Both are allowed. Both are human. But only one of them gets to wear the self-care badge.

A bath, care. Wine, not care. An early night, care. Doomscrolling, not care. A proper meal, care. Skipping dinner because you can’t be bothered, not care. Once you start running things through this filter, the whole landscape of your evenings rearranges itself. You stop performing self-care and start actually doing it. You also stop punishing yourself for the not-care stuff, because you’ve stopped pretending it was ever care in the first place.

The genius of the test is that it removes the moral panic. Wine isn’t evil. It’s just not medicine. You’re allowed to drink it. You’re allowed to enjoy it. You’re not allowed to keep telling yourself it’s healing you when the evidence every Saturday morning is screaming otherwise. Honesty is the bit that frees you, not abstinence. The wine isn’t the problem. The story you’ve been telling yourself about the wine is the problem.

What To Actually Reach For Instead

The hardest part of breaking the wine-as-self-care loop isn’t giving up wine. It’s having other tools that work fast enough to compete. Wine has speed on its side. It hits in ten minutes. Most genuine regulation strategies take longer, which is why we don’t reach for them when we’re fried. So you’ve got to stock the toolkit before the bad day arrives, not during it.

Speed is everything. A cold shower. Ten minutes of walking outside, even just around the block. Putting on the most ridiculous song you own and dancing badly in the kitchen. Lying flat on the floor with your legs up the wall. Heavy blanket on the lounge with the lights dimmed. Calling a friend who lets you complain without trying to fix you. These all work faster than you think, but only if you’ve actually got them on standby. If you wait until you’re already pouring the glass, the brain has made its decision and you’re not winning that fight.

The other piece, and this is the bit no one tells you, is that real self-care is often genuinely boring. A glass of water. Going to bed twenty minutes earlier. Eating something with protein in it. Putting your phone in another room. None of it photographs well. None of it makes a cute Instagram story. But cumulatively, this stuff is what actually rebuilds a wrecked nervous system. Wine is the dramatic gesture. Boring care is the actual maintenance. Both are available to you, but only one of them shows up for you tomorrow.

You’re Allowed To Want More Than Numb

If you’ve been calling wine your self-care, you don’t need to spiral about it. You weren’t being stupid. You were coping with a brain and a life that ask a lot of you, and you found something that took the edge off. That’s not a moral failing, babe. That’s adaptation. The wellness industry sold us a story and we bought it, and now we’re allowed to send it back for a refund.

The shift isn’t about quitting wine or becoming the kind of woman who says she “doesn’t really drink” while making sustained, intense eye contact at parties. It’s about getting honest. About not labelling things medicine when they’re not. About letting wine be wine, which is a sometimes treat that’s lovely in the moment and forgettable in the morning, and letting actual care be actual care, which is the unsexy stuff that quietly rebuilds you while you sleep.

You’re allowed to want more than the edge being taken off. You’re allowed to want to actually feel better, not just feel less. The first move is being honest about which one your Friday night glass is really delivering, and the second move is making sure the rest of your toolkit isn’t empty. That’s it. That’s the whole assignment. Now go drink some water before bed like the responsible chaos goblin you actually are.

We Need to Stop Clapping for Basic Decency – Chaos, Crumbs and Clarity

In today's episode of Chaos, Crumbs and Clarity, we're unpacking why we need to stop clapping for basic decency. You know the script. A man texts back within twenty-four hours and we're screenshotting it to the group chat. A man plans a date more than three hours in advance and we call him a unicorn. A man manages to listen, pay attention, and behave like a fully formed adult, and our nervous systems short-circuit because we genuinely don't know how to receive it.Here's the truth nobody is saying out loud. The bar has been dragged so low that Satan himself needs a chiropractor after a competitive round of limbo. We've been culturally trained to be grateful for behaviour that should not require gratitude. We've been told these things are bonuses when they're actually the entry requirement. And in the meantime, women have been quietly doing the basic decency thing forever, without applause, while men get standing ovations for outputs we generated for them.Today we're talking about why a great man is genuinely just an average woman, who benefits when the bar stays low, the invisible labour women have been performing for free for centuries, and the friend-test that cuts straight through every excuse we've ever made for mediocre men. Let's get into it.For more visit BryJaimea.com or follow over on IG @BryJaimea

If this post helped, inspired, or made you smile, you can support my work with a tea or tip over on Ko-fi. Every bit helps keep the chaos flowing.