The Gut Punch That Arrived Politely
I was mid-conversation with a friend when it happened. Not a dramatic revelation. Not a lightning bolt. More of a quiet, slow-dawning oh. The kind that lands gently because I practice mindfulness, so most things arrive as a soft hum rather than a scream. But make no mistake. It was a gut punch. It just came wrapped in good manners.
We were talking about someone we both knew. Same person, wildly different experiences. My friend had witnessed this third person’s behaviour firsthand. She’d seen the receipts. And yet, when I raised it, she told me she didn’t see anything wrong with what had happened, and that we’d simply have to agree to disagree. I sat with that for a moment. I took a breath. And then something inside me very quietly filed the paperwork.
Because here’s the thing. Agree to disagree works beautifully for opinions. Pineapple on pizza. Whether to make your bed daily. Whether Emily in Paris is peak television or a slow erosion of civilisation. You can disagree on those forever and still share a laugh and a glass of Savvy B. But moral alignment? Ethics? What you consider acceptable behaviour toward another person? That’s not a matter of taste. That’s the architecture of who you are.
Values Aren’t a Vibe, They’re a Foundation
I’m a Taurus. I say that not as an excuse but as a full explanation. My friendships are built on values. Not proximity, not history, not the fact that we’ve known each other since before smartphones and bad decisions. Values. And specifically, integrity sits at the very top of that list, above shared interests, above humour, above even a mutually excellent taste in restaurants.
Friendships require trust. Not the soft, casual kind where you trust someone to keep a secret about your terrible haircut in 2008. The real kind. The kind where you know, without needing to check, that this person would handle a situation involving you with the same ethics they’d want applied to themselves. That’s the baseline. Without it, the whole thing is a beautiful-looking structure with no foundation, and I have been inside enough buildings like that to know they fall.
When she told me she didn’t see anything wrong, what I actually heard was: I don’t see what you see. I don’t value what you value. And that wasn’t a judgement of her. It was information. Useful, clear, and ultimately kind information, because it saved me from investing further in a dynamic that would never quite hold.
The Bit That Stung More Than Expected
The thing is… It wasn’t one thing. That’s what I kept coming back to. It was the accumulation. In a single conversation, she assumed I hated people I’d simply moved on from. She questioned what was so special about my pie, which, no. She raised an eyebrow at my friendship with my ex, as though a woman maintaining a genuine, solid, loving friendship with a former partner is somehow suspicious rather than, I don’t know, emotionally evolved and actually quite lovely. Each thing on its own might have been a passing comment. Together, they painted a picture I couldn’t unsee.
Because what it told me, collectively, was that she didn’t know me. Not really. She had a version of me that didn’t quite match the actual person sitting across from her. The me she’d constructed in her head carries grudges, makes questionable life choices, and apparently can’t be trusted around puff pastry. The real me has moved on from people without drama, built something genuinely beautiful with someone I once loved differently, and makes an excellent pie. These are not minor misreadings. These are foundational.
And that’s the moment a friendship stops feeling like a friendship and starts feeling like a performance. When someone doesn’t know your actual values, your actual heart, or your actual life, you’re not close. You’re just familiar. Familiarity and closeness look the same from a distance but they feel completely different from the inside. And once you notice the difference, you can’t unknow it.
You’re Allowed to Curate
Friendships don’t need a formal job description, but if they did, shared values would be in the first line. Not matching aesthetics. Not the same taste in restaurants or the same opinion on whether a film was good. Actual values. The ones that determine how you treat people, how you show up when things get hard, and what you’re willing to overlook when someone you care about is on the receiving end of something unkind. That’s the scaffolding. Everything else is decoration.
When that scaffolding doesn’t match, the friendship can still look fine from the outside. You can still laugh together, still share a meal, still have a lovely time at a birthday party. But underneath, there’s a quiet instability. Because if your ethics don’t align, your trust can only go so far. You’ll find yourself editing what you share, bracing for reactions that don’t land the way you expected, or realising, slowly, that you can’t fully rely on this person to handle a situation involving you with the same integrity you’d bring to one involving them. That’s not a small thing. That’s the whole thing.
And yet we carry guilt about this like it’s a personality flaw. We tell ourselves we’re being too rigid, too sensitive, too much. We’re not. You are allowed to require ethical alignment from your close friendships. You’re allowed to quietly step back from dynamics that don’t feel right without owing anyone an explanation or a tribunal. Curating your people isn’t coldness. It isn’t arrogance. It’s just knowing what a friendship actually needs to function, and being honest with yourself about whether it has it.
Curate Your People Like a Taurus Curates a Playlist
The best metaphor I have is this: A Taurus does not shuffle. We build playlists with intention, with feeling, with a quiet stubbornness that says this is the energy I want and I’m not compromising it for filler. We will cut a song we used to love if it no longer fits the mood. No guilt. No ceremony. Just an honest read of what belongs and what doesn’t.
Your friendships deserve the same energy. Not cold, not cruel, just considered. The people in your life should feel like songs you actually want on the playlist, not tracks you skip every time but can’t quite bring yourself to delete. Life is too short and your capacity for meaningful connection is too valuable to spend it maintaining friendships that cost you more than they give.
Lulu, my chaos demon in a fluffy black coat, has never once spent time near someone whose energy he doesn’t like. He doesn’t explain himself. He doesn’t file an appeal. He just relocates. Quietly. With absolute confidence. And honestly, I’m taking notes. Back yourself. Curate accordingly. Your people are out there, and they share your values, not just your history.
We Need to Stop Clapping for Basic Decency – Chaos, Crumbs and Clarity
If this post helped, inspired, or made you smile, you can support my work with a tea or tip over on Ko-fi. Every bit helps keep the chaos flowing.
Check Out My Other Forms
Discover more from Life & Style with Bry Jaimea
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
